Vehicles that stop for pedestrians could be a gift to thieves.
Tim Harford points out that Dieselgate — when VW designed cars that tried to guess when they were undergoing emissions test and dial back their pollution — wasn’t the first time an industry designed its products to cheat when regulators were lookin…
In a new paper published in the peer-reviewed Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice, sociologists and criminologists from University at Buffalo (SUNY), the University of Alabama, Kennesaw State University, the State of Georgia, and Georgia State …
Lee Jae-yong is nominally “vice-chairman” of Samsung, but his father, Samsung chairman Lee Kun-hee, is considered to be a mere figurehead, with Lee Jae-yong as the true boss of the company.
As a result, LEAs are increasingly hacking directly into the suspect’s devices (computers, phones, TVs, cars), installing trojans (tiny pieces of software that can do almost anything and collect almost everything without restriction).
This is something new. Unsurprisingly, in many countries, the laws regulating the legitimate use of trojans are just as new, notably US Rule41 and the UK IP Bill, laws that authorize LEAs to hack into suspects’ devices, with few constraints and with an unsophisticated approach .
In Italy, the Civic and Innovators parliamentary group – which includes, among others, Andrea Mazziotti, Chairman of the Constitutional Affairs Committee, Stefano Dambruoso, a well known anti-terrorism prosecutor, and Stefano Quintarelli, an italian internet pioneer and entrepreneur – has recently introduced a bill on the matter.
It took nearly two years of work to draft the proposal, with the involvement of many experts and stakeholders; among them: a former speaker of the Parliament, civil rights activists, law enforcement officers, computer forensics researchers, prosecutors,law professors, IT security experts, anti-mafia and anti-terrorism departments and politicians.
This complex law proposal tries to address most of the technical issues related to the use of trojans, while guaranteeing individual rights and protecting the public from the possible abuse of government trojan.
The main concept behind the law is that a trojan shall not be allowed to do everything, but only what has been specifically authorized by a judge’s signed warrant.
* A Telephone Wiretapping Warrant is required to listen a Whatsapp call .
* A Remote Search and Seizure Warrant is required to acquire files on remote devices.
* An Internet Wiretapping Warrant is required to record web browsing sessions.
* The same kind of warrant that would be required for planting a physical audio surveillance bug is required to listen to the surrounding environment with the device’s microphone.
The proposal aims to update the framework of guarantees and limitations already provided by the criminal code, in light of the quick development of computer science, and the consequent threats to citizens’ privacy.
For example, according to the bill, if a device is searched and seized remotely during an investigation, the owner must be notified when the investigation ends. In fact, a similar provision already exists for “physical” house searches.
However, there are also very complex technical challenges that this proposal try to address, by specifying many technical and operational requirements that have to be met to legally use trojans in an investigation:
b. Every operation carried on by the trojan or through its use must be duly documented and logged in a tamper proof and verifiable way, using cryptographic time-stamping and digital signing, so that its results can be fairly contested by the defendant during the inter partes hearing.
c. The trojan, once installed, shall not lower the security level of the device where it has been activated
d. Once the investigation has finished, the trojan must be uninstalled or, otherwise, detailed instruction on how to self-remove it must be provided.
e. Trojan production and uses must be traceable by establishing a National Trojan Registry with the fingerprint of each version of the software being produced and deployed.
f. The trojans must be certified, with a yearly renewal of the certification, to ensure compliance with the law and technical regulation issued by the ministry.
g. Extracted data must be stored in the prosecutor’s servers and must be protected from third-party access with encryption.
h. Trojans have to be directly operated by police, and not by private contractors.
One would ask: how would that impact companies that develop and sell such kind of trojans?
Should the proposal become a law, they would need to update their software to comply with the new technical regulations and they would have to deposit their source code to the competent authority, in order to keep their business going on in Italy (and in any other country that adopted a similar regulatory framework).
The proposal is under public consultation. . There, judical and technical conversations are being held to further collect input from a wider public.
The Law Proposal, along with it’s Technical Regulation Proposal, is online. Of course, it is written in Italian, but an English summary is available: “Rules governing the use of government trojan with respect for individual rights”.
(Image: calflier001, calflier001, CC-BY-SA)
Civil asset forfeiture is a perfectly foreseeable outcome of the overbroad War on Drugs: it allows the cops to seize your belongings and charge them — not you! — with being the proceeds of a crime. Then it’s up to you to figure out how to prove tha…
In 2009, then-PM Vladimir Putin engineered a Russian ban on slot machines in a bid to starve Georgian mafiyeh of funds, the resulting glut of used slots gave Russia’s own criminal gangs cheap testbeds to use in a project to reverse-engineer the machi…
Tens of thousands of women in the Indian state of Uttar Pradesh have complained to police about harassing phone calls from creepy men who bought their phone numbers from the operators of mobile phone recharging stations; they say the operators snea…
Ross Compton, a 59-year-old homeowner in Middletown, Ohio called 911 in September 2016 to say that his house was on fire; there were many irregularities to the blaze that investigators found suspicious, such as contradictory statements from Compton …
The New Jersey DA’s office just announced that it had arrested New York’s Habib Chaudhry in connection with a $200M credit-card fraud; Mr Chaudhry joins 19 others who’ve pleaded guilty to the frauds.